Badger 1 VS Badger 5 (Similarities & Differences) In 2019

The Insinkerator is one of the well-known brands when it comes to garbage disposals as they originally invented them back in 1927. Most people just look at a price before buying a garbage disposal. We have made this article to help you fully understand the differences between 8 features that the Badger 1 and Badger 5 have to offer and what makes each product different from one another.

Here you may find an easy way to look at the power, RPM (revolutions per minute), dimensions and weight, the feeder type, size of the grinding chamber and what it is made from, the price and many more details about each product.

Similarities Between the Badger 1 Vs Badger 5

The Badger 1 and Badger 5 are almost identical units. They have the same grinding chambers and grinding features. They also have the same RPM, dimensions, impeller technology, and installation process.

Differences Between the Badger 1 and Badger 5

Both units vary in their price by a very small amount. They also have different strength motors which also means they vary in weight. The Badger 5 has a 1/2 HP motor making it 50% stronger than the Badger 1. Lastly, they each offer warranties that are different lengths.

Which is better? Badger 1 Vs Badger 5

The differences between both models are quite small, but can also make a big difference. For a couple of extra bucks, I would invest in getting the Badger 5 as it offers a stronger motor and a longer warranty.

Can I replace a badger 1 with a badger 5?

Both garbage disposals are interchangeable with one another. Their features are almost identical and they even use the same power cord making the replacing process quite simple.

Badger 1 VS Badger 5 In 2019

ModelBadger 1Badger 5
Power1/3 HP1/2 HP
RPM17251725
Dimensions & Weight7 x 7 x 13 inches, 13 lbs7 x 7 x 13 inches, 14 lbs
Feed TypeContinuousContinuous
Grinding Chamber Capacity26 Oz26 Oz
Grinding System MakeGalvanized SteelGalvanized Steel
Warranty1 Years2 Years
Compare Prices Online$$

We will discuss the differences between – the grinding chambers, impellers, performance and power, RPM, dimensions and weight, installation process, warranty, and finally the price. We will compare both the Badger 1 and Badger 5 and pick a winner for each category.

Before picking a winner we will take into considerations the remarks that previous Badger owners have mentioned regarding their experiences with the product. Let’s get started!

Badger 1 & 5 Grinding Chamber Comparison

You may be asking yourself what is a grinding chamber and why is it important? The grinding chamber is where all the action happens. The larger your family the bigger grinding chamber you should have to ensure that the grinding process does not take a long time.

The first thing when considering grinding chambers is determining the size of your family. Another common feature is the batch or the continuous feeder type. Both the Badger 1 and the Badger 5 offer a continuous feed allowing you to constantly add more kitchen scraps as the garbage disposal grinds away.

The last feature that makes a big difference is the grinding technology. Some higher-end products will offer a double or triple grinding feature. What this ultimately does is turn your kitchen scraps into powder.

However, do not be alarmed the most common grinding technology is a single stage grinding system. This is exactly what both the Insinkerator Badger 1 and Badger 5 offer.

Badger 1 & Badger 5

Both the Badger 1 and Badger 5 offer:
  • A 26 oz. grinding chamber
  • They have a continuous feeder
  • Single stage grinding system

Badger 5

  • The Badger 5 also has a 26 oz. grinding chamber.
  • It has a continuous feeder.
  • Has a single stage grinding system.

Winner: Since the grinding features are identical for both the Badger 1 and the Badger 5, we have a tie.

Impeller Differences Between The Badger 1 & 5

Many have the common misconceptions that garbage disposals work very similar to a blender. As a matter of fact, there are no blades involved! The Insinkerator Badger 1 and Badger 5 have impellers. These impellers sit on a grinding ring that spin to create pressure and basically convert your food into small food particles.

These food particles are pushed out of the garbage disposal with the water and flushed straight into your pipe. Believe it or not, garbage disposals are helping households become more eco-friendly. They allow you to easily get rid of food waste cutting down your household waste by 20%!

Badger 1 & Badger 5

  • Both models have impellers not blades.
Winner: Both the Badger 1 and Badger 5 have the same impeller technology installed making this a tie feature as well.

Badger 1 & 5 Motor Strength & Performance Comparison

The strength of the motor can be correlated directly to the performance of the garbage disposals. There is no such thing as one horsepower (HP) fits all. As a matter of fact, you should take into consideration how large your family is, how often you cook to determine what HP is best for your household.

Garbage disposals usually offer 4 different types of HP. Starting with the lowest and most common HP is 1/3. Then we have the 1/2 HP. Next up is the 3/4 HP. Lastly, we have the 1 HP motor. The stronger the HP also means the more expensive the garbage disposal can be. Now let’s see what horsepower each garbage disposal offers.

Badger 1

  • Has a 1/3 HP motor.

Badger 5

  • Has a 1/2 HP motor.

Winner: The winner for this round is the Badger 5 as it has a stronger HP.

RPM Comparison

What does RPM stand for? RPM means revolutions per minute, this is the measurement used to determine how fast machines usually function. RPM is important in garbage disposals because the lower the RPM means the more likely your garbage disposal could possibly get jammed.

However, with higher RPM also comes more noise. Normally lower RPM models mean the noise level is quite low. To avoid any concerns with low RPM models look for models that offer an exterior or automatic unjamming feature.

Badger 1 & Badger 5

  • Both garbage disposals have a 1725 RPM. This is a relatively low, yet strong enough RPM to safely get rid of your kitchen scraps.

Winner: Both the Badger 1 and Badger 5 have the same RPM giving us another tie.

Size & Weight

The dimensions of a garbage disposal truly come down to your preference and the space of your kitchen. For seniors or smaller homes, having a compact size garbage disposal is key to ensure that valuable under the sink storage space is not lost. However, if your kitchen is large this is not much of a concern.

Weight, however, is another story. Some heavy garbage disposals can cause damage to the sink and cause leaks in your kitchen. With that being said most prefer to have the lightest model install in their kitchen to avoid any future issues. Both of the Badger 1 and Badger 5 have the same dimensions but have a slight difference in weight.

Badger 1

  • The Badger 1 weights 13 lb.

Badger 5

  • While the Badger 5 weights 14 lb.
Winner: Badger 1 takes the win as it is a pound lighter than the Badger 5.

The Installation Process (Is there a difference)?

Each garbage disposal has a different installation process. Luckily the Insinkerator models have a relatively easy process. The easiest part about the installation is that their models come with a stainless steel quick lock sink mount. This allows you to easily uninstall or replace the unit with any of their other models.

**Keep in mind that not all the tools you may need to install the garbage disposals may be included!**

Badger 1 & Badger 5

  • Both models are easy to install.
  • They include the dishwasher connection.
  • Power cord needs to be purchased SEPARATELY for both models.

Winner: Since the installation process is identical for both units. We have another tie for the installation feature.

The Warranty Difference on The Badger 1 & 5

Both the Badger 1 and Badger 5 are made in the US which makes dealing with warranties a lot easier. Insinkerator warranties cover the parts and labor which help save you a lot of stress should you need to use your warranty. They call this the “We Come To You” warranty.

Most warranties only cover the parts, so this makes Insinkerator stand out from the other companies.

Badger 1

  • This unit offers a 1 year warranty.

Badger 5

  • While the Badger 5 offers a 2 year warranty.

Winner: Badger 5 offers a longer length warranty taking the win for this feature.

Price Difference Between The Badger 5 & 1

The last and probably most researched feature is the price. Both models are truly budget-friendly option compared to some models that are offered in the market. Check out more info on what is the best garbage disposal for your household.

Badger 1

  • The Badger 1 is normally listed around $10 cheaper than the Badger 5.

Badger 5

  • The Badger 5 is normally list a bit more expensive as they offer a stronger motor and a longer warranty.
Winner: The winner of this round is the Badger 1 as it is cheaper than the other.

Final Recount:

Badger 1: 6 / 8

Badger 5: 6 / 8