Badger 500 vs Badger 5 In 2019

Did you know that the Insinkerator brand was the ones who invented the original garbage disposal back in 1927? This is no surprise on why they are so popular in the market! This article has been written to guide you to understand the differences between 8 features that the Badger 5 and Badger 500 have.

Below, you may find an easy way to compare the power, RPM (revolutions per minute), dimensions and weight, the feeder type, size of the grinding chamber and what it is made from, the price and many more details about each garbage disposal.

Similarities Between the Badger 5 Vs Badger 500

Both the Badger 5 and Badger 500 offer similar technology and build features. For example, they have identical grinding chamber sizes and their makings. 

They both have a continuous feeder type, the same RPM, motor strength, installation process, and warranty.

Differences Between the Badger 5 and Badger 500

The smaller differences between both garbage disposals are the weight and the price. Another slight difference is that the Badger 500 has rust free impellers while the Badger 5 only offers a stainless steel finish. 

The biggest difference between both of the garbage disposals is the size. The Badger 500 is hands down a larger model.

Which is better? Badger 5 or 500

Both the Badger 5 and the Badger 500 are really good units. Although the have the same size motor the Badger 500 has much larger dimensions than the Badger 5. 

For this reason alone many have voted the Badger 5 to be an all-time favorite because we all know that under sink space is truly valuable for the kitchen!

Can I replace a badger 5 with a badger 500?

Since the installation process is identical and it comes with a compatible stainless steel sink mount the Badger 5 can easily be replaced by the Badger 500 and vice-versa. All you have to keep in mind is that the Badger 500 will require more under the sink space.

Badger 5 vs Badger 500 In 2019

ModelBadger 5Badger 500
Power1/2 HP1/2 HP
Dimensions & Weight7 x 7 x 13 inches, 14 lbs12.63 x 6.31 x 6.31 inches, 13.9 lbs
Feed TypeContinuousContinuous
Grinding Chamber Capacity26 Oz26 Oz
Grinding System MakeGalvanized SteelGalvanized Steel
Warranty2 Years2 Years
Compare Prices Online$$$

In this article, we will be looking at the difference between – the grinding chambers, impellers, performance and power, RPM, dimensions and weight, installation process, warranty, and the price. We will compare both the Badger 5 and Badger 500 and pick a winner for each category.

Before picking a winner we will take into considerations the remarks that previous Insinkerator Badger owners have mentioned regarding their experiences with the product. Let’s get started!

Grinding Chamber Comparison

Many often do not take into consideration the importance of the grinding chamber and the materials they are made from. The first thing to consider is looking for a grinding chamber that is made from stainless steel, galvanized steel, or a rust- free material since it will be in constant contact with water.

Next look into the size of the grinding chamber. If the grinding chamber is too small it will take you much longer to get rid of your food scraps and it will take up some of your valuable time!

The last feature when looking into grinding chambers is determining if the garbage disposal offers a continuous or batch feeder. The continuous feeder allows you to easily continue to add food as the spaces frees up in the grinding chamber.

Badger 5 & Badger 500

  • They both have a 26 oz. grinding chamber made from galvanized steel.
  • Single stage grinding system.
  • They have a continuous feeder.
Winner: Since the grinding features are identical for both the Badger 5 and the Badger 500 we have a tie in this feature.

Impeller Comparsion

When it comes to garbage disposals the main assumption people make is that they have sharp blades to grind up the food- similar to a blender effect. You would be surprised to find out that in fact, garbage disposals have zero blades!

Instead, all the Insinkerator garbage disposals have impellers. These impellers are on a grinding ring that spin to create pressure and grind up your food into tiny food particles that get washed away with water into your waste pipe.

Impellers can be made of different materials. Let’s see what the Badger 5 and Badger 500 are made from.

Badger 5

  • Has stainless steel impellers.

Badger 500

  • Has rust resistant impellers.
Winner: Since the Badger 500 offers a rust resistant finish on the impellers they take the win for this feature.

Performance and Power

The strength of the motor can determine how well the garbage disposal may perform in your home. You should take into consideration how large your family is and how often you cook to determine what HP is best for you and your family. The smaller your family is the smaller HP that you will need.

Garbage disposals can be purchased in 4 different types of HP. Going from lowest to greatest – 1/3 HP, 1/2 HP, 3/4 HP, and lastly 1 HP motors. The stronger the HP also means the more expensive the garbage disposal can be and how loud it can get.

The 1/2 HP motors can effectively grind up items like coffee beans, chicken bones, and other common food scraps into a liquid to avoid them clogging up your pipes. This strength is normally recommended for smaller households.

Badger 5 & Badger 500

  • Both have a 1/2 HP motor.
Winner: Both garbage disposals have the same exact motor and strength making this feature a tie between the two.

RPM Comparison

Many do know what RPM is and the importance of this number before purchasing a garbage disposal. RPM means revolutions per minute, this is how we usually measure machines and motors to determine how fast they usually function. 

RPM is important in garbage disposals because the lower the RPM means the more likely your garbage disposal could possibly get jammed.

However, with higher RPM also comes more noise levels. Normally lower RPM models mean the noise level is quite low. Many have recommended keeping your mind at ease by looking at any models that have a good RPM and also have an exterior or automatic unjamming feature.

Badger 5 & Badger 500

  • Both garbage disposals have a relatively low and strong enough RPM to get rid of your kitchen scraps safely. Although 1725 is a good number, it is still relatively noisy.
Winner: Both the Badger 5 and Badger 500 have the same RPM making them tied in this feature as well.

Dimensions & Weight

Before purchasing a garbage disposal keep in mind the size of your kitchen, but most importantly how much space you have under your sink. This is key as your garbage disposal will sit under there and larger models can take up valuable storage space. Also, keep in mind that garbage disposals with larger models are also well-known to be least noisier than the compact size models.

Badger 5

  • The Badger 5 weights 14 lbs.
  • Compact unit

Badger 500

  • While the Badger 500 weights 13.9 lbs.
  • This model has slightly larger dimensions.
Winner: Technically speaking, the Badger 500 is slightly lighter which means it wins this feature.

Installation (Which Is Easier To Install)

The first thing you want to look for I reviews is the installation process. Some garbage disposals can have a very complicated installation process that will require for you to hire a plumber. If you are replacing a previous Badger unit the process is even easier! All you have to do is simply twist off the old garbage disposal and twist on the new unit.

This process is so easy because all Badger garbage disposals come with a stainless steel quick lock sink mount. All purchases may not include everything you need to install the garbage disposal. Take a close look before purchasing to see if you need to add other parts like a power cord, or dishwasher connection. We recommend checking more info on the best rated garbage disposals.

Badger 5 & Badger 500

  • Installation is a breeze for both models.
  • Each unit includes the dishwasher connection, but the power cord is not included!

Winner: Since the installation process is exactly the same for both garbage disposals. We have another tie for the installation feature.

Are The Warranties The Same?

All Insinkerators come with the famous “We Come to You” warranty. Each model may vary in the length of the warranty. However, the main reason this warranty is so famous is that they literally come to you and cover the replacement part and also the labor included!

Badger 5 & Badger 500

  • Both units come with a 2 year warranty.

Winner: The Badger 5 and Badger 500 are tied since they offer the “We Come To You” warranty up to two years.

Feature 8 – Price

The first feature people normally look before buying a garbage disposal is the price. Both of these models are relatively budget-friendly. However, one is cheaper than the other.

Badger 5

  • The Badger 5 is usually listed around $20 cheaper than the Badger 500.

Badger 500

  • Since the Badger 500 has the rust free impellers, it is normally slightly more expensive.
Winner: The Badger 5 is around $20 cheaper than the other model making this the most budget-friendly option when it comes to cost.

Final Recount:

Badger 5: 6 / 8

Badger 500: 7 / 8